Re: Proper attribution of patches

[Harold L Hunt II <huntharo at msu dot edu>]

Thomas Dickey wrote:

> On Tue, 23 Dec 2003, Harold L Hunt II wrote:
>
>
> > No, that is not good enough.  You should amend your change log entry to
> > attribute the patch to Ralf and you should apologize to the X community
> > at large for being so sloppy with attributing credit.
>
>
> yes, you're right.

Thanks.

>  now I'll have to scrutinize your commits more closely
> to see who actually did the work.

Hold on.  Lets assume that I had made the change.  So, we are assuming, 
hypothetically, that the patch should have been attributed to me.  In 
that case you are still in the wrong because you attributed the patch to 
yourself, not to me (even though I did not make the change).  You cannot 
escape the fact that *you* *took* credit for the patch; you did not 
assign it to the wrong person due to a mistake in interpreting the 
change log entries, you actually *took* credit for yourself and didn't 
mention the fact that you got the patch from another project.

Harold